| |
:: Retail Industry Audit Technique Guide (ATG) - Chapter 4:
Examination Techniques for the Food and Beverages Industries (Mobile
Food Vendors)
Chapter
4
- Examination
Techniques
for the
Food and
Beverages
Industries
(Mobile
Food
Vendors)
Introduction
Mobile
food
vendors
can be
observed
on many
street
corners,
outside
warehouse
stores,
courthouses
or any
high
volume
industrial
center.
They
appear
to
operate
strictly
in cash
and have
no forms
of
internal
controls,
so the
potential
for
unreported
income
is
great.
There
are two
types of
catering
trucks:
hot
trucks,
such as
Mobile
Food
Preparation
Vehicles
(MFPV),
which
allow
food to
be
prepared
as
customers
order;
and cold
trucks,
such as
Industrial
Catering
Vehicles
(ICV),
which
sell
only
prepackaged
foods.
The hot
trucks
have at
least a
driver
(which
is
usually
the
taxpayer),
and a
cook,
who may
be a
family
member.
The cold
trucks
only
need a
driver
in most
instances,
since it
is a
self-service
vehicle;
however,
they are
not
limited
to just
the
driver.
Income
This
type of
business
will be
largely
cash
intensive,
since
most
individuals
purchasing
items
from a
mobile
vendor
pay in
cash.
Accordingly,
gross
receipts
will be
the main
focus
for the
examination.
The
examiner
will
expect
to see
large
cash
deposits
to the
business
bank
account.
To
verify
all cash
is
deposited
or
accounted
for the
examiner
must
analyze
the
markup
percentage.
The
examiner
should
expect
to see a
consistent
markup
percentage
of about
100% on
cold
foods
sold and
about
200% on
hot
foods
sold.
For
example,
if an
item is
purchased
for
$0.50,
it will
generally
sell for
$1 or
more.
If bank
deposits
are used
by the
taxpayer
to
determine
gross
receipts
or by
the
examiner
to test
gross
receipts,
care
must be
taken to
make
sure any
cash
paid out
for
business
and
personal
expenses
is added
back to
the
analysis.
Estimating
gross
income
of
mobile
food
vendors
can be
accomplished
with the
investment
of
relatively
few
examination
hours,
and can
result
in a
very
accurate
estimate
of the
gross
income
actually
earned
from the
operation.
If an
indirect
method
is
necessary,
the
examiner
must
obtain
sufficient
testimony
from the
taxpayer
in the
interview
to
evaluate
the
credibility
of the
testimony
and to
corroborate
the
calculations.
Additionally,
the
examiner
and
taxpayer
must be
able to
verify
the cost
of goods
sold
with
some
reliability.
The
markup
is
generally
consistent
for most
products
sold by
mobile
vendors,
so the
percentage
on cost
of goods
sold can
be
calculated
as
follows:
Total
Sales -
Cost of
Goods
Sold ÷
Cost of
Goods
Sold =
Markup
Percentage
Then,
Cost of
Goods
Sold *
100 +
Markup =
Gross
Receipts
appropriately
marked
up for
Sale.
Cost of
Goods
Sold
Inventories
are
seldom
reported
and may
not be
material
in
nature,
since
food
must be
sold or
discarded
soon
after
purchase
and
there is
usually
no space
to
maintain
additional
stores.
Expenses
may
often be
paid in
cash, so
the
examiner
must
ensure
that all
cost of
goods
sold are
included.
This is
especially
important
if
income
will be
estimated,
since
additional
cost of
goods
sold
using a
markup
percentage
of
100-200%
will
produce
substantial
gross
receipts.
Some
driver/owners
of food
trucks
are
linked
to
specific
commissaries
that
stock
and
store
their
trucks
overnight.
The
commissary
is a
wholesale
supermarket
where
the
drivers
are able
to buy
food and
supplies
in
bulk.
Most
trucks
assigned
to a
commissary
are
required
to park
their
vehicles
there
overnight
for
washing,
unloading,
and
morning
loading
of food.
Expenses
The
examiner
may
encounter
the
following
types of
expenses:
Vehicle
Expense
- There
is
little
question
that
some
transportation
expenses
are
incurred
by most
mobile
vendors.
Both
food and
supply
items
are
often
picked
up by
the
vendors,
rather
than
being
shipped
or
delivered.
The
examiner
should
be alert
for
overstated
business
miles
without
any
consideration
for
commuting.
In some
areas
mobile
vendors
use the
services
of
“strikers”
to wash
and load
trucks.
These
“strikers”
work at
the
large
catering
wholesalers
and are
usually
paid in
cash.
As
always,
the
taxpayer
must be
able to
identify
individuals
paid,
provide
the
individual’s
SSN and
perform
the
required
information
reporting.
If these
steps
are not
taken,
if would
be
difficult
for the
taxpayer
to prove
a bona
fide
business
expense
exists,
since he
did not
treat it
in a
business-like
manner.
It would
be
equally
difficult
to prove
an
expense
was
paid,
especially
if it
was
allegedly
paid in
cash.
Penalties,
Fines,
Tickets
- The
examiner
should
be
cognizant
of
possible
violations
of the
health
code,
which
may be
deducted
as a
business
expense.
Some
common
health
code
violations
include
improper
food
temperatures,
unsanitary
conditions,
infestations,
sale of
home
prepared
foods
and
operating
without
a valid
health
permit
or
business
license.
Costs
incurred
to
remedy
the
situation,
such as
a repair
to the
heating
device,
would be
a
deductible
business
expense.
Fines,
penalties
or
tickets
are not
deductible.
Glossary
Cold
Truck
Catering
trucks
which
sell
pre-packaged
food
such as
cold
sandwiches,
for
example,
self-service
industrial
catering
vehicle.
Commissary
Wholesale
supermarket
where
catering
truck
drivers
purchase
food in
bulk.
Fleet
Operator
Person(s)
who own
a number
of
catering
trucks
and hire
individuals
to drive
their
trucks.
Food
Sales
An
industry
which is
designed
to
manufacture
or
purchase
food
products
for sale
to
wholesalers
or the
public.
Hot
Trucks
Catering
trucks
which
prepare
and
serve
hot food
such as
full
breakfast,
hamburgers,
burritos,
tacos,
etc.,
for
example,
mobile
food
preparation
unit.
|
|